Two K-Cup Boxes Make The Takeout’s List of Top-Rated Costco Coffees

Two boxes of K-Cups made The Takeout’s list of the highest-rated coffees at Costco, a roundup built from what Costco shoppers have rated and talked up rather than the outlet’s own taste test.

The first is Peet’s Decaf House Blend, a dark roast that The Takeout says sits at 4.8 stars across nearly 10,000 reviews. It comes in a box of 60 recyclable pods for $44.99, and the outlet lists it as online only. The second is Kirkland Signature Organic Summit Roast, a medium roast in a 120-pod box for $41.99.

Run the numbers and the gap is big. The Peet’s box works out to about 75 cents a pod, which is ordinary for a name brand. The Kirkland box is about 35 cents a pod, which is cheap by any K-Cup standard.

The rest of the list is beans, ground coffee, cold brew cans and instant. The one that matters to pod owners is Kirkland’s Dark Roast Colombian, a 3-pound tub of ground coffee for $24.99 that The Takeout notes works in reusable pods.

Our take: if you have a Costco card and a Keurig, the Summit Roast box is the one to try first, since it’s about half what most brands charge per cup. Decaf drinkers pay about twice as much per cup for the Peet’s. And if you want to go cheaper still, that Colombian tub in a reusable filter beats both. Our best reusable K-Cups guide covers the filters, and what a Keurig really costs per cup has the full math.

More coffee pod news

All news