Tasting Table: Keurig Pods Cost Less, Mostly Thanks to Subscriptions
Keurig’s K-Cups usually cost less than Nespresso capsules, Tasting Table reports, though the gap depends a lot on whether you buy them on a subscription. It’s the same conclusion Daily Meal reached a few weeks ago, with a few fresher numbers attached.
On the Nespresso side, Tasting Table lists Original capsules from 90 cents for a basic ristretto up to $1.05 for a limited seasonal flavor. Vertuo runs higher, from $1.08 for a ristretto to $1.60 for the seasonal Blueberry Cheesecake. The outlet points out that Original machines can take third-party capsules, while Vertuo owners don’t have that option.
Keurig’s prices look better mostly because of its subscription discount. Per Tasting Table, Italian Roast pods are 91 cents each bought once, or 68 cents on a recurring order, and Wild Mountain Blueberry drops from 81 to 62 cents in a 24-count box. Dunkin’ Original Blend is pricier at 99 cents a pod, or 74 cents with a subscription. Buy your pods off the shelf at the store, the outlet says, and the two brands can end up fairly close.
Tasting Table also notes the pods aren’t interchangeable, that more than 70 brands make K-Cups, and that the coffee itself is different: Nespresso leans strong and espresso-like, Keurig closer to drip.
Our take: the cheapest pod is the one you’d buy anyway, on whatever discount you’ll actually keep up with. If you’re a Vertuo owner, Nespresso’s own sales are about your only lever. We ran the full math, machine included, in what a Keurig really costs per cup, and Original owners can trim the bill with our Nespresso-compatible pods picks.