House Digest Says Swap Your Keurig for a Bean-to-Cup Machine

House Digest is making the case for retiring your Keurig in favor of a bean-to-cup machine, one that grinds whole beans and brews in a single step. The pitch: about the same push-button ease, no pods to throw away, and a smaller coffee bill over time.

The savings argument is all about the pods. By House Digest’s numbers, K-Cups run from roughly 40 cents to $1.10 each, so one person drinking a 75-cent pod every morning spends close to $275 a year on pods alone, and twice that in a two-coffee household. Grocery-store whole beans at about 75 cents an ounce, at around 0.38 ounces a cup, come to a little over $100 a year for the same daily habit. That’s roughly $175 a year saved per person, the outlet figures.

The catch is the machine. House Digest puts basic Keurigs at around $90 list (often closer to $50 on sale) and bigger models at $170 to $220. A drip brewer with a built-in grinder is about $100, while bean-to-cup espresso machines run $500 to $1,600, which takes a few years of savings to pay back.

Our take: the math holds up, but you don’t need a new machine to get most of it. A reusable K-Cup filter filled with your own ground coffee cuts the pod cost and the plastic, and it works in the Keurig you already own. Our best reusable K-Cups guide covers the ones worth buying, and what a Keurig really costs per cup runs the full numbers. If you’d rather drop pods for good, the $100 grinder-brewer is the cheap way to try it.

More coffee pod news

All news